Monday 24 February 2014

Students, say goodbye to snow days






Schools around the country grappled this winter with rough weather, unsafe roads and power outages, which meant a lot of time for students -- including these from the Washington, D.C., area -- to play in the snow. After 10 snow days, schools in <a href='http://ift.tt/Mn9BOl' target='_blank'>Prince William County, Virginia</a>, are reducing elementary recess to 10 minutes per day and adding other instructional days. Here's how other schools with extreme bad weather cancellations are making time for students to learn.Schools around the country grappled this winter with rough weather, unsafe roads and power outages, which meant a lot of time for students -- including these from the Washington, D.C., area -- to play in the snow. After 10 snow days, schools in Prince William County, Virginia, are reducing elementary recess to 10 minutes per day and adding other instructional days. Here's how other schools with extreme bad weather cancellations are making time for students to learn.

After 10 snow days, students in Logan County, West Virginia, will attend full days of school on some planned early release days, and will attend extra days of school at the end of the year. These students in nearby Beckley, West Virginia, had some time off for snow angels in mid-February.After 10 snow days, students in Logan County, West Virginia, will attend full days of school on some planned early release days, and will attend extra days of school at the end of the year. These students in nearby Beckley, West Virginia, had some time off for snow angels in mid-February.

Students in Rossville, Indiana, will be attending school on Saturdays to make up for 10 snow days the district had called by mid-February, <a href='http://ift.tt/1fkQFGN' target='_blank'>CNN affiliate WLFI reported</a>. Here, a mother and child cleared snow in northern Indiana after several inches fell in early February. <!-- --> </br>Students in Rossville, Indiana, will be attending school on Saturdays to make up for 10 snow days the district had called by mid-February, CNN affiliate WLFI reported. Here, a mother and child cleared snow in northern Indiana after several inches fell in early February.

Many Georgia schools canceled more days than usual due to snow and ice, including during this mid-February storm that made Braselton, Georgia, area interstates tough to handle. Catoosa County, Georgia, school officials plan to add 20 minutes to the school day.<!-- --> </br>"I believe adding 20 minutes each day is better for families, and for student achievement, than using spring break or adding days at the end of the year," Superintendent Denia Reese said in <a href='http://ift.tt/1fkQFGR' target='_blank'>a statement to families</a>. <!-- --> </br>Many Georgia schools canceled more days than usual due to snow and ice, including during this mid-February storm that made Braselton, Georgia, area interstates tough to handle. Catoosa County, Georgia, school officials plan to add 20 minutes to the school day."I believe adding 20 minutes each day is better for families, and for student achievement, than using spring break or adding days at the end of the year," Superintendent Denia Reese said in a statement to families.

Illinois Department of Transportation snow plows worked the roads in the southwestern part of the state in early February, when inches of snow came down and wind chills fell below zero. Students from Edwardsville, Illinois, schools expect to end school on May 28 instead of May 20, and might use an "act of God" exemption to prevent making up even more days, <a href='http://ift.tt/1dVdxN4' target='_blank'>CNN affiliate KMOV reported</a>.<!-- --> </br>Illinois Department of Transportation snow plows worked the roads in the southwestern part of the state in early February, when inches of snow came down and wind chills fell below zero. Students from Edwardsville, Illinois, schools expect to end school on May 28 instead of May 20, and might use an "act of God" exemption to prevent making up even more days, CNN affiliate KMOV reported.

Schools across the state struggled with heavy snow and ice, like this storm that hit Charlotte, North Carolina, in mid-February. Students in Watauga and Avery counties missed days in the double digits by then. Some schools planned to extend the school year by a few days, add minutes to school days and add classes on Saturdays. <!-- --> </br>Schools across the state struggled with heavy snow and ice, like this storm that hit Charlotte, North Carolina, in mid-February. Students in Watauga and Avery counties missed days in the double digits by then. Some schools planned to extend the school year by a few days, add minutes to school days and add classes on Saturdays.

Several Michigan school districts saw greater-than-average numbers of cancellations due to snow and ice. Portland Public Schools used 10 snow days before the end of January, and planned to add extra days to the end of the school year. "This is unprecedented certainly in my 23 year tenure as the superintendent in Portland and actually, I've never experienced this in my 40 years in education," Portland Superintendent Charles Dumas told <a href='http://ift.tt/Owglv7' target='_blank'>CNN affiliate WXMI</a>.<!-- --> </br>Several Michigan school districts saw greater-than-average numbers of cancellations due to snow and ice. Portland Public Schools used 10 snow days before the end of January, and planned to add extra days to the end of the school year. "This is unprecedented certainly in my 23 year tenure as the superintendent in Portland and actually, I've never experienced this in my 40 years in education," Portland Superintendent Charles Dumas told CNN affiliate WXMI.

Many school districts around Springfield, Missouri, had high numbers of snow days. Schools build and least six snow days into their calendars, but districts like Fair Grove schools turned holidays and teachers' professional development days into instructional days.Many school districts around Springfield, Missouri, had high numbers of snow days. Schools build and least six snow days into their calendars, but districts like Fair Grove schools turned holidays and teachers' professional development days into instructional days.

Students from Henderson County, Kentucky, headed to buses after an early dismissal due to weather on February 4. Around the state, several districts held school on President's Day, while others cut back on planned days off.Students from Henderson County, Kentucky, headed to buses after an early dismissal due to weather on February 4. Around the state, several districts held school on President's Day, while others cut back on planned days off.

Rough weather had residents of eastern Pennsylvania pushing out of snow and ice throughout the winter. For students in the Pocono Mountain schools and other districts, that means heading to school on previously planned holidays and teacher development days.Rough weather had residents of eastern Pennsylvania pushing out of snow and ice throughout the winter. For students in the Pocono Mountain schools and other districts, that means heading to school on previously planned holidays and teacher development days.









  • Schools are facing extreme numbers of weather cancellations this year

  • Some schools are trying virtual school days to prevent learning interruptions

  • Individual educators have turned to online learning to keep students on track




(CNN) -- Earlier this month, Zak Terzini roused himself about five minutes before his English class began and didn't panic. Instead, the high school sophomore grabbed his iPod and checked on a class discussion of "The Autobiography of Malcolm X" without even getting out of bed.


A snowstorm -- another one -- had canceled classes in the Pascack Valley Regional High School District in northern New Jersey, but educators and students wouldn't be taking a day off. Before the snow fell, even before the official school cancellation call, teachers were prepped, parents were warned and students had received enough assignments to fill a snow day.


School leaders around the country are tearing up their calendars to cram in more teaching time after extreme numbers of weather cancellations. Some are eliminating holiday breaks and professional development plans, adding minutes and days to the school clock or even cutting recess and opening school on Saturdays.


But a few are trying something different: virtual school days that continue learning, even while staff and students are stuck at home.





Virtual school on snow days?




Tornadoes and snowstorms hit the country




Outrage over open New York City schools




School officials rap snow day

This could be the snow day of the not-too-distant future. As much as students love them, school officials loathe calamity cancellations, those days off caused by snowstorms, hurricanes, illness outbreaks or power outages. They cost time and money, disrupt the flow of learning and leave parents in a lurch.


By mid-February, the 2,000-student Pascack Valley Regional district had already used its three built-in snow days for the school year, and Superintendent P. Erik Gundersen didn't want to chip away at spring break.


With snow in the forecast, Gundersen alerted teachers that he expected to cancel classes and asked them to develop lessons students could complete from home. A day later, when students logged in on school-provided laptops, they were able to ask teachers questions, work through assignments or jump into class discussions, even if they sometimes took breaks to shovel the walkways.


Pascack Valley Regional officials still don't know if the day will count toward their state-mandated total. The New Jersey Department of Education hasn't decided yet. But the superintendent already counts it as a learning success.


"We think it's worthwhile and productive, why not do it?" Gundersen said. "This is what we've been doing in the corporate world for quite some time ... balancing family life with work and getting things done. Why shouldn't high school kids?"


'We're lucky, right?'


Schools in similar circumstances are coming to the same conclusion. Staff and students at Coyle and Cassidy High School in Taunton, Massachusetts, tried their first virtual school days after cancellations began to pile up this year.


They were ready. All of the private school's 500 students now have an iPad purchased by his or her parents, and they've used the tablets in class and at home since the start of the school year.


They were lucky, too, to have the "perfect snow days," said Kathleen St. Laurent, vice principal of academic affairs at Coyle and Cassidy -- no widespread power outages, no long stretches of days off, a forecast that gave teachers time to prepare and a student body that already knew the drill.


Teachers found creative ways to record and share lessons, and many spent the virtual days fielding students' questions, St. Laurent said. Parents loved it, and students, well, they "were a little bummed out."


Many slept in, and some complained there was too much work -- there will be more coordination among teachers in the future, St. Laurent said. Still, participation was high.


"With kids, a day out is a lot," St. Laurent said. "This way, everyone could have the same lessons, just as if they were in the classroom."


READ: This isn't your mama's gym class


Going into Pascack Valley Regional's virtual school day, teachers feared some students wouldn't log in, despite warnings that the day's assignments would count toward their grades. It wasn't a problem: The virtual school day had higher attendance than they expect on a normal school day, the superintendent said.


"It was energizing, invigorating," said social studies teacher Karen Kosch, who has taught in Pascack Valley schools for 28 years. "I don't mean to sound corny, but we were all in it together."


No serious technical glitches were reported. Next time, Kosch said, she'll have a stronger sense about how to pace conversations held among dozens of kitchen tables and couches.


As one student put it, Kosch said, " 'I don't know what the big fuss is. We do this every day.' "


Kosch, of course, remembers the years before everyone had a laptop, but she had to agree: "We're lucky, right?"


'This is a vacation day'


In areas where weather cancellations are common, students have long been expected to haul home backpacks full of books and assignments before snow days, and some schools have tried to lighten the load through technology. In Ohio, schools can use "blizzard bags," online or hard copies of assignments to keep students learning and days counting.


Even at schools that provide an online bank of activities, it can be complicated to keep an entire class moving forward, said Dick Flanary, deputy executive director for programs and services for the National Association of Secondary School Principals.


"Technology offers some promise in terms of mitigating some impact," Flanary said. "Depending on a particular child, what kind of learner a child may be, how diligent will they be to engage on a snow day in some sort of academic pursuit when 'this is a vacation day'?"


Tougher yet is the technology. Most schools don't have one-to-one programs that supply students and staff with computers, and home Internet connections can still be spotty. Teachers polled for a 2013 survey by Pew Research Center's Internet & American Life Project said more than half of students had sufficient access to digital tools at school, but only a fifth could access digital tools at home.


READ: The real class behind the Super Bowl commercial


Even without schoolwide technology programs, individuals teachers are finding ways to keep their students on track.


The day before a February snowstorm swept through the Atlanta area, teacher Jordan Kohanim sent her students home with the same instructions she repeated all year: Check the class website.


Most of her students at Northview High School outside Atlanta have made it a habit, and with the help of tools such as Remind101, a service that allows teachers to send text messages to students, she was confident they would follow through. When an earlier stretch of bad weather caught schools by surprise, several students checked the website and completed assignments without her asking, she said.


It's not the highest quality education out there, Kohanim said -- there's little chance for interaction when students are asked to read a passage, watch a video and write a response. But Kohanim made herself available to answer questions and check work, and it helped to keep students focused until they returned the following week.


"I wouldn't say I'd like that to go on for long," said Kohanim, who has maintained a class website since she started teaching seven years ago. "We don't have time to stop on snow days. We have to keep moving."


'A nerd's dream'


On the morning of February 13, Pascack Valley High School English teacher Matt Morone was maybe a quarter of the way through his morning coffee when students began to respond to "The Autobiography of Malcolm X" on Twitter. Some teachers used Google documents or learning tools such as My Big Campus, Schoology or Canvas for the virtual school day, but he especially liked seeing the conversation draw people who weren't even in his class.


"This was a nerd's dream for me," said Morone, himself a graduate of Pascack Valley Regional schools.


For students, it was a lesson in time management and self-driven learning, one he's sure they'll take to college. For teachers, it was a chance to try ideas they've only pondered before. For everyone else? Proof.


"We are in a fortunate position here ... but you don't need a whole lot of infrastructure to do some of the stuff we're doing," Morone said. "There are means by which to do this. A lot of Twitter discussion is through iPads, cell phones -- whichever glowing rectangle you want to use, that's fine."


READ: Will Google Glass go to your class?


Students were learning other lessons, too.


Zak Terzini discovered he had to be concise because he only had 140 characters to make his point about "Malcolm X." He listened more, too. He's "a talker," he said -- an athlete, the class president, a guy who's always ready to jump in with an opinion.



Don't miss out on the conversation! Follow us on Twitter @CNNschools or on CNN Living on Facebook for the latest stories and to share your perspective.


Online, he finally heard some quieter classmates speak up.


"Having it all out on Twitter, people have that little barrier," he said. "It was kind of open to a lot more opinions."


Between shoveling snow, watching an Olympic hockey game and making himself a sandwich, he listened to a teacher explain some algebra concepts, completed some history work and forced himself to figure out some stoichiometry problems that he might've given up on if he'd been in the same room as the chemistry teacher.


"I thought, 'We're just going to get extra homework.' It was kind of ridiculous to have a virtual day," he said. "But the mood definitely changed after it went successfully. They got us involved. They were assigning the right amount of work.


"I got done at 2:51, and I can't believe I actually got done."


Would you want virtual school days to replace traditional snow days in your area? Tell us why or why not in the comments, on Twitter @CNNschools or on CNN Living's Facebook page !



Is this world's best burger joint?


Fergburger's Mr. Big Stuff. The name says it all.


Fergburger's Mr. Big Stuff. The name says it all.






  • Fergburger's fresh handmade burgers are Queenstown's best known secret

  • So popular people often wait an hour for a burger

  • Despite success, Fergburger hasn't franchised or expanded into a chain




Editor's note: This month's CNNGo TV adventure explores the gourmet scene, wildlife and breathtaking natural wonders on New Zealand's South Island. More: www.cnn.com/cnngo


(CNN) -- It's a tough headline to swallow.


Best burger in the world?


Yeah, right.


Cue the commenters getting carried away "my burger joint is better than yours" rants.


Walk them past Fergbuger on the main street of New Zealand's adventure capital of Queenstown, however, and the doubters might quickly turn into believers.


Colloquially known as "Ferg's," the burger joint is swollen with customers who spill out every opening hour, happy to wait around an hour at peak times for a feed.


And "peak time" describes most of the store's 21-hour day.


International tourists can be seen emerging with their takeouts, delicately removing a Little Lamby (lamb burger) or Sweet Bambi (venison), reverently folding the brown paper bag with the treasured logo and carefully tucking it in a backpack.


Next step, burger selfie straight to Facebook.


"My mates in Taiwan/Sweden/Canada/wherever are gonna be jealous of this. Big check mark in that Kiwi trip must-do box."




Probably the last time the line didn\'t reach out the door.

Probably the last time the line didn't reach out the door.



Like checking out the Eiffel Tower in Paris, Ferg's has become the compulsory stop in Queenstown.


If Michelin stars were still dished out the way they originally were, Fergburger would bag at least a couple, arguably three. ("Exceptional food, well worth a special journey.")


Among burger lovers anyhow.


And on any given day (save Christmas when Ferg's closes for a breather) burger lovers pick from quite a big menu -- around 20 variants, ranging from the standard Fergburger to the Southern Swine (beef, bacon, avocado) to the Chief Wiggum (pork belly) to stuff for impurists like the Bun Laden (falafel), Codfather (cod) and Holier than Thou (tofu).


MORE: Queenstown and beyond: Adventure, beauty, muttonbirds


Tasty origins


Ferg's opened in 2001, a true hole in the wall, hard to find place that quickly rose in popularity -- especially among the ski/boarding, backpacker and adventure crowd.


It moved to its current location on Shotover Street a few years later.


Slightly more room but still pretty cramped with 10 cooks and servers in the kitchen and 50 employees total.


Close proximity burger-flipping and managing hangry (hungry meets angry) crowds makes for a tight and well-run bunch of employees.


"The staff has the philosophy that Ferg loves you -- we treat others the way they want to be treated, and I think that's really the key to our success," says Fergburger general manager Steve Bradley.


The success comes in spite of the challenges of operating a 24-hour (including the three hours of cleaning each day) restaurant in a small resort town, with a limited and transient staff and difficult food supply lines for fresh produce.


Where's Ferg?


The secret behind Queenstown must-visit restaurant doesn't sound like much of a secret -- hand-make everything with fresh produce every day.


The other secret isn't so well-guarded either.


After shelling out a fair bit of coin for a bungee jump, Shotover Jet boat ride or day on the slopes, NZ$10 to $15 for a hearty burger is extremely appetizing.


While Bradley is happy to discuss management-type stuff, he's less revealing when faced with tougher questions.


Like, who the hell is Ferg?


READ: NZ South Island's 13 most beautiful photo ops


"There are so many stories I don't even remember what the real legend is -- he may have been the first person to swim naked to Glenorchy or -- my favorite -- the first man to go down Shotover River in a barrel," says Bradley.


Ferg's owner prefers to remain hidden from the public, and management refuses to say anything about him/her.


"We're about the customer and the product, and providing great service and fresh, honest food," says Bradley.


While franchise offers have been coming thick and fast, Ferg management hasn't been swayed.


"We think we're in a really special, beautiful part of the world and that's been a nice part of our formula," says Bradley.


"It would have to take an extra special idea to entice us to go somewhere else."


The closest thing to another Ferg's is the opening of Fergbaker in 2011, a bakery next door that does a Kiwi favorite, the meat pie, proud.


For hungry visitors to Queenstown, this is the fallback when Fergburger crowd's prove too big a mountain to climb.


Fergburger , 42 Shotover St., Queenstown Town Center; +64 3-441 1232; open 8:30 a.m.-5 a.m., daily except Christmas Day.


Recommended burgers: Little Lamby (Prime New Zealand lamb, mint jelly, lettuce, tomato, red onion, alioli, tomato relish), NZ$12.50 ($10) and Sweet Bambi (Wild Fiordland deer with a Thai plum chutney, lettuce, tomato, red onion, alioli).


MORE: CNNGo in South Island, New Zealand



Hagel orders review of nuke force





  • Incidents of misconduct prompt call for independent review

  • Officers cheated on test, a general was relieved of command over behavior

  • U.S. officials say nuclear arsenal remains secure, despite problems with personnel




(CNN) -- Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel is ordering an independent review of the nation's nuclear force following revelations of misconduct involving officers, the Pentagon said on Thursday.


Top leaders of the force plan to meet with Hagel in coming weeks, Defense Department spokesman Rear Adm. John Kirby said.


The action follows a recent disclosure that nearly three dozen Air Force officers at a nuclear missile base in Montana were involved in cheating on a proficiency test.


That followed a decision by senior military officials to discipline a general with nuclear oversight responsibilities whose personal misbehavior involving alcohol and women on an overseas trip got him into hot water.


Kirby said "clearly, we've got some issues here," but added the Pentagon remains confident the U.S. nuclear arsenal is secure.


Earlier this month, the U.S. Air Force announced 34 officers with the 341st Missile Wing were implicated in the cheating scandal after a drug possession probe that involved two of those officers.


Sixteen officers were ultimately found to have actually cheated on the monthly proficiency exam while the rest knew the answers had been shared with others and did not report the violation, the Pentagon said.


All those disciplined in the investigation are no longer certified to conduct nuclear operations.


There are approximately 190 officers overseeing readiness of nuclear weapons systems in Montana, meaning the scandal has touched nearly 20% of that force.


Other scandals include October's news that Air Force Maj. Gen. Michael Carey, who oversaw nuclear weapons, was relieved of his duties after he boozed, fraternized with "hot women" and disrespected his hosts during an official visit to Russia, Air Force officials said.


There was no indication Carey's behavior compromised sensitive nuclear information or went beyond drinking, dancing and fraternizing with the women, officials said.


Also in October, Navy Vice Adm. Tim Giardina, who also oversaw nuclear weapons forces, was formally relieved of his duties as deputy chief of U.S. Strategic Command, according to Rear Adm. John Kirby, the Navy's chief of information.


A military official said his demotion was connected to allegations that he used counterfeit gambling chips at an Iowa casino.


In August, the same missile unit at Malmstrom linked to the test cheating scandal failed a safety and security inspection "after making tactical-level errors -- not related to command and control of nuclear weapons," the Air Force Global Strike Command said.


The 341st Missile Wing operates about 150 of the 450 Minuteman III nuclear-tipped intercontinental ballistic missiles in the U.S. force, according to an Air Force statement.


A failed inspection does not mean that the safety of the nation's nuclear arsenal is at risk, global strike commander Lt. Gen. Jim Kowalski said in August.


And in April, an Air Force commander stripped 17 of his officers in Minot, North Dakota, of their authority to control and launch nuclear missiles after they did poorly in an inspection. They were ordered to undergo 60 to 90 days of intensive refresher training on how to do their jobs.


CNN's John Crawley, Barbara Starr, Zach Wolf and Tim McCaughan contributed to this report.



What Israelis are talking about


The beachfront of Tel Aviv, Israel.


The beachfront of Tel Aviv, Israel.






  • Michael Oren: Israel sits in a region bristling with conflict and hostile to its presence

  • He says one topic stirring attention is number of streets named for women in Tel Aviv

  • Israelis have always lived with the threat of war, and put it in perspective, he says

  • Support for a two-state solution is strong in Israel today, he says




Editor's note: Michael Oren is the former Israeli ambassador to the United States. His books include "Power, Faith, and Fantasy: America in the Middle East: 1776 to the Present."


(CNN) -- Like Americans, Israelis begin their day by watching one of several television news shows. These highlight the pressing issues facing the country. But Israel, of course, is not just any country, but a contested and often controversial Jewish state situated in the epicenter of an overwhelmingly Muslim and constantly roiling Middle East.


One would expect, then, to hear commentators on these shows discussing the latest glitch in the peace talks with the Palestinians, the recent terrorist bombing just beyond Israel's southern border with Egypt, or the revelation of more advanced rockets in the arsenal of Hezbollah in Lebanon. But the topic on Israel's leading morning show this week was none of these. The top issue, rather, was the percentage of Tel Aviv streets named for women.


Turns out that women's studies scholars and feminist activists have examined Tel Aviv street names and discovered that the overwhelming majority of them are named for men. While preparing for work, I kept one eye on the television and listened, fascinated, as representatives of women's rights groups argued passionately for gender equality in Tel Aviv street-naming. They made a compelling case and even the show's hosts, who are generally testier than their American counterparts, were convinced. I, too, was impressed, and not only by the discussion, but also by the very fact that it was taking place.



Michael Oren


From Tel Aviv it is roughly a two-hour drive to Mafraq in Jordan, the temporary home of tens of thousands of Syrian refugees, making it the country's second-largest city.


From Tel Aviv, one can drive three hours north — less than the distance between New York and Boston — and arrive in Damascus, in the thick of the Syrian civil war. Or one can drive east from Tel Aviv and in eight hours reach Iraq, where an estimated thousand people are being killed each month by suicide bombers.


A similar excursion of about nine hours concludes in Tahrir Square in time for the latest confrontation between Egyptian protesters and police. A veritable firestorm is engulfing the Middle East, and Israel's Tel Aviv is just a short commute from its flash points.


Yet it was women's rights, not the upheaval encompassing Israel on all sides, which highlighted the morning news. One explanation, certainly, is that Israelis need diversion from the chaos closing in on them, and what could be more distracting than a debate about signposts?


After all, the question of whether to name a street after Golda Meir is certainly easier than asking if Israel can coexist with a nuclear-armed Iran.


Another claim, one that is sometimes voiced by visiting statesmen, is that Israelis have it too good to think about the hard choices they face in the peace process. In fact, support for the two-state solution is vastly higher among Israelis today—more than 60%--than it was during the years of suicide bombing, when it was close to zero. But the real reason for Israel's interest in women's rights at this time is much more fundamental and reveals this country's secret. The reason is fortitude.


Unique among the world's nations, Israel has never known a second of peace. Since its creation in 1948, and for many years before that, the country has been in a relentless state of war. And yet, in spite of that trauma, Israelis simply refuse to live abnormal lives.


Almost militantly, they insist on normality. Call it a bubble, call it a fantasy, but the fact is that it works. In the midst of regional insanity, Israelis have built several of the world's leading universities, a cutting-edge high-tech sector, a universal health care system, and a wildly vibrant democracy.


Yes, there is controversy. There is still no two-state solution for Israelis and Palestinians and no end in sight for the Iranian nuclear program. Israeli intelligence recently reported that terrorists are pointing 170,000 rockets and missiles at the Jewish state. But on the streets of Tel Aviv, quite possibly the most threatened city on Earth, the cafes and cultural centers are packed, the food is superb and people are arguing why more of those streets are not named for women.


Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.


Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion.


The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Michael Oren.



What the West owes Ukraine






Ukrainians got their first glimpse inside ousted President Viktor Yanukovych's compound near Kiev when the presidential guards abandoned the grounds on Saturday, February 22, 2014.Ukrainians got their first glimpse inside ousted President Viktor Yanukovych's compound near Kiev when the presidential guards abandoned the grounds on Saturday, February 22, 2014.

A CNN crew toured the grounds on Sunday, February 23 and took these images around the residence. Here, a galleon-style ship that was used for parties is docked at a marina near the house.A CNN crew toured the grounds on Sunday, February 23 and took these images around the residence. Here, a galleon-style ship that was used for parties is docked at a marina near the house.

People roamed around the mansion and its vast grounds after long-simmering anti-government protests ousted Yanukovych over the weekend.People roamed around the mansion and its vast grounds after long-simmering anti-government protests ousted Yanukovych over the weekend.


"The protesters walked in their thousands, because the roads were jammed, to the most fantastical show of fled ruler," says <a href='http://ift.tt/1drmleb'>CNN's Nick Paton Walsh.</a> "They knew they were poor and he was rich, but not like this; not quite so insultingly extravagant."

"The protesters walked in their thousands, because the roads were jammed, to the most fantastical show of fled ruler," says CNN's Nick Paton Walsh. "They knew they were poor and he was rich, but not like this; not quite so insultingly extravagant."


"What for?" was the common refrain from Ukrainians marveling at the excess of the place, according to Yulia Marushevska, 25, whose online video entitled <a href='http://ift.tt/1fzGuTj'>'I am a Ukranian'</a> went viral.

"What for?" was the common refrain from Ukrainians marveling at the excess of the place, according to Yulia Marushevska, 25, whose online video entitled 'I am a Ukranian' went viral.

"Remarkably, there was no looting and nothing was stolen, because that's what they say Yanukovych did," reports Paton Walsh. "In the end he fled in the presidential helicopter and not in his massive river boat for partying.""Remarkably, there was no looting and nothing was stolen, because that's what they say Yanukovych did," reports Paton Walsh. "In the end he fled in the presidential helicopter and not in his massive river boat for partying."


Protesters expressed disbelief at the opulence in which Yanukovych lived, including peacocks, vintage cars and gaudy statues.

Protesters expressed disbelief at the opulence in which Yanukovych lived, including peacocks, vintage cars and gaudy statues.


A full suit of armor stands in a vacated room of the house. Yanukovych is facing a warrant for the "mass killings" of civilians.

A full suit of armor stands in a vacated room of the house. Yanukovych is facing a warrant for the "mass killings" of civilians.


In his last known public act, he delivered a televised speech Saturday from Kharkiv in which he rejected Parliament's ouster and vowed to fight. He said: "I don't plan to leave the country. I don't plan to resign. I am the legitimate President."

In his last known public act, he delivered a televised speech Saturday from Kharkiv in which he rejected Parliament's ouster and vowed to fight. He said: "I don't plan to leave the country. I don't plan to resign. I am the legitimate President."

Yanukovych's ouster and disappearance capped a weekend of dizzying developments after Parliament voted to oust Yanukovych as a concession to relentless protests, which led to the deadliest violence in the country since its independence 22 years ago.Yanukovych's ouster and disappearance capped a weekend of dizzying developments after Parliament voted to oust Yanukovych as a concession to relentless protests, which led to the deadliest violence in the country since its independence 22 years ago.


Paton Walsh describes the residence as "a bizarre, enormous, empty mansion. Gaudy but vacant; the luxury never seemed to end."

Paton Walsh describes the residence as "a bizarre, enormous, empty mansion. Gaudy but vacant; the luxury never seemed to end."


Pictured is a bottle of the former President's own vodka.For now, Parliament Speaker Oleksandr Turchinov will take over Yanukovych's duties and has promised a new interim government by Tuesday and new elections in May.

Pictured is a bottle of the former President's own vodka.For now, Parliament Speaker Oleksandr Turchinov will take over Yanukovych's duties and has promised a new interim government by Tuesday and new elections in May.








1



2



3



4



5



6



7



8



9



10



11



12








  • Timothy Snyder: We're witnessing an extraordinary event, a revolution in Ukraine

  • He says Ukraine's population did not run away from regime's violence, but stood firm

  • Ukrainians don't want to accept a Russian-style regime in return for Russian money, he says

  • Snyder: The West now must provide financial and other support for Ukraine's democracy




Editor's note: Timothy Snyder is Housum professor of history at Yale University and author of "Bloodlands: Europe between Hitler and Stalin."


(CNN) -- A true revolution doesn't come every day. The word "revolution" appears all around us, in commercial advertisements and political propaganda, until it seems to have lost all meaning.


The most minor tumult, the smallest change, and immediately we pronounce the word. And so when the real thing arrives, with tyranny and blood, with masses striving for freedom, with an ancient regime destroyed and a new one born, we might just fail to see its significance.


The spark that began the revolution was something called Europe: a trade agreement with the European Union that many Ukrainians saw as a chance to enter a world of free trade rather than government syndicates, and the rule of law rather than overwhelming corruption. When President Viktor Yanukovych, after months of promised, rejected the deal in November, Ukrainians protested.



Timothy Snyder


The students were the first to reach the "Maidan," the main square of Kiev. They are the ones who already considered themselves Europeans, and took a European future for granted. After the riot police were sent to beat them, they were joined by the "Afghans," the veterans of the Soviet war in Afghanistan.


Then came the businessmen, the professionals, the people who had hoped to make an honest living, but found themselves thwarted by unpredictable taxes and corruption. In December, hundreds of thousands of people, from all parts of the country and all walks of life, were on the streets.


Then Russian President Vladimir Putin appeared with a proposal. Why not take 15 billion euros from Russia instead of playing around with Europe? Although the Russian side promised that the loan was without conditions, Russian leaders then explained that disbursements could only follow when political stability had been established.





Hunt is on for Ukraine's president




What happens next in Ukraine?




Ukraine's own diplomat blasts Yanukovych

In January, President Yanukovych formally did away with basic freedoms. A package of legislation introduced by a pro-Russian legislator and rushed illegally through parliament introduced a number of laws that closely resembled Russian models. Ukrainians reacted as Americans would if the Bill of Rights one day disappeared.


After weeks of peacefully tolerating beatings, torture and disappearances, some of the protesters took the fight to the police. Once again Moscow made clear that the next tranche of the loan would depend upon political stability. Last week a truce was declared, and a day of mourning announced for the protesters who died. On the day of mourning, the Ukrainian government mounted snipers on rooftops. They shot dozens more protesters dead.


The Ukrainian protesters did not do what most of us would have done. They did not run away. Instead they came in ever greater numbers. They did not react with a bloody counterattack, as well they might have. They simply, and amazingly, built their barricades, stood their ground and said they would give their lives for their freedom. At this point, the world began to react -- finally. The Polish and German foreign ministers arrived to negotiate the transition that many people had wanted for weeks: a weakening of the Yanukovych's power and accelerated elections.


This was far more than protesters could have expected before the mass killing, but far less than they wanted afterward. The compromise agreement specified that both sides would cease violence.


Yanukovych's police seemed to understand what he did not: that this meant the end of his rule. They disappeared from the fight, and ceased to protect him. Yanukovych disappeared. Parliament convened, and in these last few days began a very thorough reform of the entire political system.


On Saturday the protesters gathered again in the hundreds of thousands to mourn their dead and to celebrate what they had achieved. Ukraine is now once again a parliamentary democracy, with presidential elections scheduled for May, and an alert population preserving the peace and watchful of its own newfound rights.


What happened in Ukraine had little to do with the outside world. Yet what happens next will.


Ukraine's previous authorities were among the most corrupt imaginable. Yanukovych's son, a dentist, earned at least $200 million in the last two years. Yanukovych sat on a toilet of gold (or two, actually) in the extraordinary mansion he has had to abandon.


The state, unsurprisingly, is close to bankruptcy. Russia has exercised influence in Ukraine by promising cash: The promise of 15 billion euros preceded the dictatorship laws, the promise of the release of a 2 billion tranche preceded the mass shootings. This sort of conditionality is what caused the revolution. Something else is called for now.


The Ukrainian revolution took place without outside help. Indeed, the men and women of the Maidan, although they want their country inside the West, were extremely disappointed with Western inaction during their revolution.


Now Western financial aid will be needed to transform that revolution into stability. The International Monetary Fund has promised loans, but this is not enough. People who risked death for the values we all claim to treasure, people who have brought a major nation back from dictatorship and to democracy deserve more than loans that will require immediate economic austerity.


They need very significant European and American financial support. This could include loans, quick free trade negotiations, financial institutions that offer microcredits, and visa-free travel for normal Ukrainians -- not just the billionaires.





If we don't understand the revolution in Ukraine, then we miss something special and unusual...

Timothy Snyder




Ukrainian oligarchs have parked hundreds of millions, if not billions, of dollars in Western banks: some of it, just possibly, illegally. Such accounts could be investigated promptly. Direct financial assistance would have to be conditional upon further reforms that ensure the restoration and the preservation of the rule of law.


This is not some idle choice. The Ukrainian revolution, like any revolution, can fail. There are plenty of Ukrainians who are confused by the revolution or oppose it, and are waiting to see what the new government will bring. Although the European Union, the United States, and China have recognized Ukraine's new authorities, Russia has not.


Russian propaganda characterizes Ukrainian activists (depending on its purpose and intended audience) as fascists, terrorists, or gays. Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev has claimed, without any evidence, that Russian citizens in Ukraine are under threat. That is the classical justification for intervention. Russian parliamentarians are now in Crimea, promising Russian citizenship to ethnic Russians there and suggesting that Russia will support a referendum on the detachment of Crimea from Ukraine and its attachment to Russia.


On the other side, among the revolutionaries are radicals who may not be satisfied by the compromises that end any revolution. Their main motivation was the end of Moscow's influence in Ukraine, and so they can be provoked. Compromise will be possible in a state that is financially stable. In one that is not, Russian policy might provoke nationalists, and conflict can begin again.


The cause of the Ukrainian protesters was not to change the world, but only to change their world. What they wanted was normality, predictability, the ability to live their lives the way they chose.


They wanted, in other words, the things that most of us take for granted. But now that their revolution has come, the world faces certain important choices. If we don't understand the revolution in Ukraine, then we miss something special and unusual: a chance to support democracy.


Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.


Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion.


The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Timothy Snyder.