Friday 31 January 2014

Are Syria, Iran playing Obama for a fool?






Hundreds of refugees make their way across the Syrian border into Jordan. Many have walked up to 20 kilometers to flee the ongoing civil war in Syria.Hundreds of refugees make their way across the Syrian border into Jordan. Many have walked up to 20 kilometers to flee the ongoing civil war in Syria.

Roughly half of the refugees making their way into Jordan are children, many carrying olives and other goods from their farms as a reminder of what they've left behind.Roughly half of the refugees making their way into Jordan are children, many carrying olives and other goods from their farms as a reminder of what they've left behind.

Jordan has deployed extra soldiers to their northern border to deal with the influx of Syrian refugees.Jordan has deployed extra soldiers to their northern border to deal with the influx of Syrian refugees.

Hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees -- many of them carrying what little they have after their homes were destroyed -- have streamed into Jordan since the start of the Syrian conflict in 2011.Hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees -- many of them carrying what little they have after their homes were destroyed -- have streamed into Jordan since the start of the Syrian conflict in 2011.

The oldest are often the last ones to make it across the border, and Jordan has deployed doctors to the border to assist with the most vulnerable. The oldest are often the last ones to make it across the border, and Jordan has deployed doctors to the border to assist with the most vulnerable.

These refugees came from the outskirts of Damascus, the Syrian capital. Like many children, this little boy walked unaccompanied across the border. These refugees came from the outskirts of Damascus, the Syrian capital. Like many children, this little boy walked unaccompanied across the border.

The boy refused to speak to CNN, but opened up to this Jordanian border security force doctor.The boy refused to speak to CNN, but opened up to this Jordanian border security force doctor.

This man told us he was 100 years old and displaced twice after his home was destroyed.This man told us he was 100 years old and displaced twice after his home was destroyed.

A father poses with his twins near the Jordanian border. The man told CNN he came across the border with about 10 other members of his family from the Damascus suburbs.A father poses with his twins near the Jordanian border. The man told CNN he came across the border with about 10 other members of his family from the Damascus suburbs.

The majority of the refugees walking across the border are women with children. Many of the men have either stayed behind to fight or have been killed during the three-year civil war in Syria.The majority of the refugees walking across the border are women with children. Many of the men have either stayed behind to fight or have been killed during the three-year civil war in Syria.

After they arrive at the border they're put into Jordanian border police trucks and taken to a remote border camp for registration. After they arrive at the border they're put into Jordanian border police trucks and taken to a remote border camp for registration.

Exhausted refugees pile into a truck for the half hour trip to the border camp, where they will be given food and water and processed.Exhausted refugees pile into a truck for the half hour trip to the border camp, where they will be given food and water and processed.

The road from the border to the camp is unpaved; here a Jordanian truck is stuck in the mud after recent spells of rain. The truck had to be pulled out of the mud by an armored personnel carrier.The road from the border to the camp is unpaved; here a Jordanian truck is stuck in the mud after recent spells of rain. The truck had to be pulled out of the mud by an armored personnel carrier.

It typically takes a day or two for new arrivals to be registered as refugees at the border camp. It typically takes a day or two for new arrivals to be registered as refugees at the border camp.

Children arriving at the base camp were overjoyed to see a playground, but after registering as refugees they still face a 400 kilometer drive to the Zaatari refugee camp.Children arriving at the base camp were overjoyed to see a playground, but after registering as refugees they still face a 400 kilometer drive to the Zaatari refugee camp.

More than 100,000 Syrian refugees currently call Zaatari refugee camp in Jordan home. It is the second largest refugee camp in the world and, if it was a city, would rank among Jordan's largest.More than 100,000 Syrian refugees currently call Zaatari refugee camp in Jordan home. It is the second largest refugee camp in the world and, if it was a city, would rank among Jordan's largest.

Roughly half of Zaatari's residents are children -- and 42% of families in the camp are led by a female head of household.Roughly half of Zaatari's residents are children -- and 42% of families in the camp are led by a female head of household.

There are several play areas for children in Zaatari, which is run jointly by the U.N. and the Jordanian government. There are several play areas for children in Zaatari, which is run jointly by the U.N. and the Jordanian government.

Safah (R) has been living for more than a year in Zaatari with her parents and five siblings. She lost her leg in a rocket attack outside Damascus. Safah (R) has been living for more than a year in Zaatari with her parents and five siblings. She lost her leg in a rocket attack outside Damascus.

Safah's father says she was an active and sociable girl before the attack. Now, he says she's become more withdrawn.Safah's father says she was an active and sociable girl before the attack. Now, he says she's become more withdrawn.

There are three schools in Zaatari. The U.N. estimates that nearly 3 million children in Syria have been forced to quit their education as a result of the civil war.There are three schools in Zaatari. The U.N. estimates that nearly 3 million children in Syria have been forced to quit their education as a result of the civil war.

This is the World Food Program's bread distribution center in Zaatari. There are two lines to get bread -- one for men, one for women.This is the World Food Program's bread distribution center in Zaatari. There are two lines to get bread -- one for men, one for women.

Every morning, an estimated 30,000 people come to collect bread for their families. On average, 500,000 portions of fresh bread are distributed daily in the camp.Every morning, an estimated 30,000 people come to collect bread for their families. On average, 500,000 portions of fresh bread are distributed daily in the camp.

This is a child friendly space, one of several in the camp. There are separate sessions for girls and boys. This is a child friendly space, one of several in the camp. There are separate sessions for girls and boys.

Rowaida Abu-Zaid used to own a salon in Syria. She now runs one of three wedding shops in Zaatari. In the summer she says she organizes up to four weddings a day.Rowaida Abu-Zaid used to own a salon in Syria. She now runs one of three wedding shops in Zaatari. In the summer she says she organizes up to four weddings a day.

There are three schools in Zaatari, but only about 20% of the children attend class.There are three schools in Zaatari, but only about 20% of the children attend class.

There are more than 23,000 children in Zaatari. Thousands more are expected to arrive in the coming year.There are more than 23,000 children in Zaatari. Thousands more are expected to arrive in the coming year.

There are more than 17,000 pre-fabricated homes in Zaatari. Each unit holds a family of five and costs $3,000. But in Zaatari's "gray market" they sell for $1,000 each.There are more than 17,000 pre-fabricated homes in Zaatari. Each unit holds a family of five and costs $3,000. But in Zaatari's "gray market" they sell for $1,000 each.

The UNHCR is working to replace all of the tents at Zaatari with prefabricated homes. The goal is to get 80,000 residents into pre-fabricated units by the summer.The UNHCR is working to replace all of the tents at Zaatari with prefabricated homes. The goal is to get 80,000 residents into pre-fabricated units by the summer.

In the meantime, the Jordanians are building a new refugee camp. Officials say it can accommodate 30,000 right now, but could end up holding more than 100,000 refugees.In the meantime, the Jordanians are building a new refugee camp. Officials say it can accommodate 30,000 right now, but could end up holding more than 100,000 refugees.








1



2



3



4



5



6



7



8



9



10



11



12



13



14



15



16



17



18



19



20



21



22



23



24



25



26



27



28



29



30








  • Syria has only removed about 4% of priority one chemical weapons, U.S. says

  • Frida Ghitis: Syria, Iran seem willing to toy with the U.S., raising doubt about negotiations

  • She says U.S. needs to make clear that it will back up its positions with action




Editor's note: Frida Ghitis is a world affairs columnist for The Miami Herald and World Politics Review. A former CNN producer and correspondent, she is the author of "The End of Revolution: A Changing World in the Age of Live Television." Follow her on Twitter @FridaGhitis.


(CNN) -- Remember Syria's chemical weapons? Yes, those, the ones the Syrian regime agreed to give up after President Obama threatened to bomb.


All of the "priority one" the most dangerous of those weapons, were supposed to be gone by December 31 last year. They're not. Almost all of them -- more than 95% -- are still in Syria despite a commitment by the Syrian President Bashar al-Assad to get rid of his deadly arsenal.


The deal to remove Syria's stock of WMD was the one tangible accomplishment of the Obama administration's approach to the Middle East's multiple crises. Now that deal looks to be failing, even as red flags also start flying along the path to a deal with Iran.



Frida Ghitis


It's hard to escape the impression that Iran and its close ally, Syria, are toying with the U.S.


America is earnestly seeking a diplomatic solution. And we should all hope diplomacy succeeds in securing an agreement that stops the carnage in Syria and one that prevents Iran from becoming a greater threat to its neighbors. But there is a reason these efforts are already running into trouble.


Secretary of State John Kerry is valiantly pursuing the suit-and-tie approach to peace, but Kerry is handicapped by the growing perception that Obama will not use military force under any circumstances. The U.S. doesn't need to release bombs to show it is powerful. What it needs to do is remind its adversaries, its enemies, that it has options beyond the well-appointed rooms of hotels along Lake Geneva.


Obama can do this by speaking directly and firmly about those choices. That alone would go a long way in reshaping some points of views, and could produce results. If it doesn't, more concrete steps would be required, from increasing material support for specific anti-al-Assad forces to a tightening of sanctions against Iran and other steps.


Diplomats can help concentrate the mind of their interlocutors when the people on the other side of the table worry about the possible cost of failure.


This is true of Syria's al-Assad, who has heard Obama's threats on the use of chemical weapons starting in the summer of 2012, and is still playing games with America while relentlessly slaughtering and starving his people.


And it is true about Iran, which just heard Obama during the State of the Union threaten to veto a plan to set the stage now for additional sanctions against Iran if negotiations fail in the next six months. Iranian officials presumably also heard the president state what so many have stopped believing: that he is prepared "to exercise all options to make sure Iran does not build a nuclear weapon."


Iran foreign minister says Obama's remarks are for "domestic consumption"


The more we hear from the Iranians, the less likely it seems that a successful agreement can be reached.


After CNN's Fareed Zakaria talked to Iranian President Hassan Rouhani last week, he concluded there's a "train wreck" on its way in negotiations. The U.S. is moving forward on the assumption that a deal would involve the dismantling of some key nuclear facilities, but Rouhani, the moderate face of the Islamist Republic, made it "categorically, specifically and unequivocally" clear that Iran has no intention of ever rolling back its nuclear program.





Playing for time with human lives




A Syrian refugee's story




Satellite photos show Syrian devastation




What's behind the new al Qaeda warning?

On Syria, I had heard rumors that the removal of its most terrifying weapons was not going as scheduled. Then an anonymous source told Reuters that the regime has delivered a dismal 4.1% of the 1,300 tons of toxic agents it has reported, "and there is no sign of more," on the way.


Then the U.S. confirmed it.


On Thursday, Ambassador Robert Mikulak, who heads the U.S. delegation to the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons, told the group that Syria is ignoring the timeline for removal of banned weapons and displaying "a 'bargaining mentality' rather than a security mentality." In addition, he said, there is little progress on Syria's commitment to destroy its chemical weapons production facilities.


If Syria's games over its chemical weapons sound familiar -- agreements followed by "misunderstandings" and endless delays -- it is because we see much the same already unfolding with Iran.


Iran's President and foreign minister are well versed in their communications strategy with the West. They are charming and fluent, speaking directly to Western publics who would like nothing better than to be done with the threat of a confrontation. And how great it would be to truly resolve the issue diplomatically.


Hope, however, is not a strategy any more than closing your eyes when you don't like what you see, as when Iranian President Hassan Rouhani tweeted that in the Geneva agreement the "world powers surrendered" to Iran. That's when the White House dismissed the worrisome statement as a play for a domestic audience.


Since then, however, one after another Iranian official has maintained they have no intention of taking apart any of their nuclear program. Without destroying any centrifuges, reactors, or other facilities, Iran can negotiate with the West, and receive political, diplomatic and economic benefits from the loosening of sanctions, as it already has. And then, as top Iranian officials have said, it can reverse any freeze and resume high-level enrichment in 24 hours. That's the vow from the top nuclear negotiator and the foreign minister.


Making matters worse, much worse, we have just learned that American intelligence officials believe Iran has essentially already reached the "nuclear breakout" capability it sought. Director of National Intelligence James Clapper told Congress this week that Iran has made "technical progress in a number of areas -- including uranium enrichment, nuclear reactors, and ballistic missiles -- from which it could draw if it decided to build missile-deliverable nuclear weapons." In other words, he concluded, the only thing between Iran and nuclear weapons is a political decision to build the bomb. Everything else is already in place.


That extraordinary revelation received little attention in the U.S., where the headlines were consumed with the crisis in ice-logged Atlanta. In other places, the news was cause for alarm. "Heaven help us," tweeted a respected Israeli journalist, "Iran can now build and deliver nukes."


How is it possible that Iran and Syria are getting away with this?


Iran and Syria are not the only countries convinced that the U.S. will not take military action. Saudi Arabia apparently has reached much the same conclusion.


After his 2012 red lines became blurred, the deal to get rid of al-Assad's chemical weapons allowed Obama to claim he had succeeded in showing consequences for their use, even if al-Assad stayed in place and the killing continued. But now it looks as if essentially nothing has changed. Except that tens of thousands more have died.


To support American diplomacy, Obama needs to erase that image of a weak America. Again, there is no need to launch attacks and deploy troops. But there is a need to show to America's enemies they cannot play the U.S. for a fool. The President needs to assert convincingly that he will be able to exercise power if that becomes necessary. Nothing would be more helpful to the chances for diplomatic success.


Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.


Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion.


The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Frida Ghitis.



No comments:

Post a Comment