Wednesday 16 April 2014

Opinion: Earn less to land a husband?






The names Betty, Gloria and Shirley probably come to mind when most think of feminists, but there's a whole group of young women -- and men -- who are working toward equality. Here is a short list -- who would you add? Tweet us <a href='http://ift.tt/1g2upq2' target='_blank'>@CNNLiving</a> with #fem2.<!-- --> </br><!-- --> </br>Malala Yousafzai is a Pakistani student and education activist, who gained international attention after she<a href='http://ift.tt/1l4kJjx'> was shot in 2012 by Taliban gunmen</a>. "I want to become a prime minister of Pakistan," she said, saying it could make her "the doctor of the whole country."The names Betty, Gloria and Shirley probably come to mind when most think of feminists, but there's a whole group of young women -- and men -- who are working toward equality. Here is a short list -- who would you add? Tweet us @CNNLiving with #fem2.Malala Yousafzai is a Pakistani student and education activist, who gained international attention after she was shot in 2012 by Taliban gunmen. "I want to become a prime minister of Pakistan," she said, saying it could make her "the doctor of the whole country."

Journalist Gloria Steinem poses with Kierra Johnson at the Ms. Foundation's Women of Vision 2013 Gala earlier this year. Johnson, the executive director of Choice USA, an abortion rights organization, has worked to mobilize youth around reproductive justice. Journalist Gloria Steinem poses with Kierra Johnson at the Ms. Foundation's Women of Vision 2013 Gala earlier this year. Johnson, the executive director of Choice USA, an abortion rights organization, has worked to mobilize youth around reproductive justice.

There's been no <a href='http://ift.tt/1l9iyH4'>shortage of ink written </a>on Tavi Gevinson, the wunderkind founder and editor-in-chief of the <a href='http://rookiemag.com/' target='_blank'>online magazine, Rookie</a>. In her 2012 <a href='http://ift.tt/Po4RSE' target='_blank'>TEDtalk on feminism</a>, she spoke about women in media: "What makes a strong female character is a character who has weaknesses, who has flaws, who is maybe not immediately likable, but eventually relatable."There's been no shortage of ink written on Tavi Gevinson, the wunderkind founder and editor-in-chief of the online magazine, Rookie. In her 2012 TEDtalk on feminism, she spoke about women in media: "What makes a strong female character is a character who has weaknesses, who has flaws, who is maybe not immediately likable, but eventually relatable."

<a href='http://ift.tt/1grDCKU' target='_blank'>Samhita Mukhopadhyay</a> is a feminist writer, speaker and digital strategist. As the former executive editor of <a href='http://feministing.com/' target='_blank'>Feministing.com</a>, she also wrote "Outdated: Why Dating is Ruining Your Love Life." Now, she works as a senior strategist at <a href='http://www.purpose.com/' target='_blank'>Purpose</a> developing digital campaigns for girls and women.Samhita Mukhopadhyay is a feminist writer, speaker and digital strategist. As the former executive editor of Feministing.com, she also wrote "Outdated: Why Dating is Ruining Your Love Life." Now, she works as a senior strategist at Purpose developing digital campaigns for girls and women.

Sammi Siegel, Emma Axelrod and Elena Tsemberis are three New Jersey teens who<a href='http://ift.tt/1l4kJzS' target='_blank'> petitioned to get a female moderator</a> for the 2012 presidential debate. CNN's Candy Crowley was named a moderator for the second debate, in which<a href='http://ift.tt/1l9ixmu'> wage parity </a>became an issue.Sammi Siegel, Emma Axelrod and Elena Tsemberis are three New Jersey teens who petitioned to get a female moderator for the 2012 presidential debate. CNN's Candy Crowley was named a moderator for the second debate, in which wage parity became an issue.

Gaby Pacheco, an immigrant rights leader and director of the <a href='http://ift.tt/1l9iyXr' target='_blank'>Bridge Project</a>, left, was accompanied by Janet Murguía, president and CEO of the National Council of La Raza, when Pacheco <a href='http://ift.tt/1hfMdLj' target='_blank'>testified before Congress</a> about the DREAM Act. Gaby Pacheco, an immigrant rights leader and director of the Bridge Project, left, was accompanied by Janet Murguía, president and CEO of the National Council of La Raza, when Pacheco testified before Congress about the DREAM Act.

Jamia Wilson is the executive director of YTH -- <a href='http://yth.org/' target='_blank'>Youth Tech Health</a> -- an organization that advances youth health and wellness through technology. She's been named one of<a href='http://ift.tt/1l9iyXC' target='_blank'> faces of the future of feminism</a> and was part of a co-founding leadership committee of SPARK Movement. Jamia Wilson is the executive director of YTH -- Youth Tech Health -- an organization that advances youth health and wellness through technology. She's been named one of faces of the future of feminism and was part of a co-founding leadership committee of SPARK Movement.

<a href='http://ift.tt/1l9iyXH' target='_blank'>Shelby Knox</a> was featured in a documentary that chronicled her teenage activism for comprehensive sex education and gay rights in her Southern Baptist community. She has been an activist for 10 years and works at Change.org on campaigns for gender justice. Shelby Knox was featured in a documentary that chronicled her teenage activism for comprehensive sex education and gay rights in her Southern Baptist community. She has been an activist for 10 years and works at Change.org on campaigns for gender justice.

Sunny Clifford is advocate for reproductive health and justice and <a href='http://ift.tt/1l4kJQx' target='_blank'>petitioned</a> for Native American women's access to emergency contraception. She was featured in the documentary "<a href='http://ift.tt/1l9ixCV' target='_blank'>Young Lakota</a>."Sunny Clifford is advocate for reproductive health and justice and petitioned for Native American women's access to emergency contraception. She was featured in the documentary "Young Lakota."









  • Conservative activist Phyllis Schlafly says equal pay is bad for women

  • Peggy Drexler: Her case that equal pay hurts women's odds of marrying is flawed

  • Drexler says reducing financial independence for women doesn't empower them

  • We need to reduce gender-based salary discrimination, Drexler says




Editor's note: Peggy Drexler is the author of "Our Fathers, Ourselves: Daughters, Fathers, and the Changing American Family" and "Raising Boys Without Men." She is an assistant professor of psychology at Weill Cornell Medical College of Cornell University and a former gender scholar at Stanford University. Join her on Facebook and follow her on Twitter @drpeggydrexler. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author.


(CNN) -- Despite the fact that Republicans recently voted down the Paycheck Fairness Act (for the third time), no one dares to argue in favor of gender-based salary discrimination.


No one, that is, except for "pro-family" activist Phyllis Schlafly, who has made a long career of telling women their place is in the home. In case you're not familiar with Schlafly, she's a veteran right-wing activist and founder 44 years ago of the Eagle Forum, a conservative interest group that, among other things, opposes abortion, vaccines and working mothers.


On Tuesday in the Christian Post, Schlafly declared that equal pay is bad, widening the wage gap is good and that the entire institution of marriage depends on men continuing to earn more than women.



Peggy Drexler


Providing women with equal pay for equal work, she wrote, would lower their chances of finding a "suitable mate," since, as Schlafly argues, women prefer to marry men who earn more than they do while men prefer to marry women who earn less.


But do they? Or is it that neither gender has had very many choices to the contrary?


Talking about the salary gap between partners is the least romantic thing in marriages. But the truth is that women have long married men who earned more than they did for one main reason: Men have long earned more than women.


It's not about desire. It's about numbers. Schlafly says that "men don't have the same preference for a higher-earning mate." Maybe that's because until very recently, the chances that men meet higher-earning women were pretty rare. They still are.


Schlafly doesn't stop there, though.


She argues that beyond the case for "saving marriage," women don't actually deserve equal pay because they "work fewer hours per day, per week, per year." While men work more than women in paid work, women work more than men if you account for unpaid work.


She goes on saying that women "place a much higher value on pleasant working conditions: a clean, comfortable, air-conditioned office with congenial co-workers" -- as if A/C and friends to eat lunch with were not things that men like as well.


She also ignores the reality that professional men and women do not receive equal treatment or consideration in the workplace. Women earn less than men -- about 84 cents to men's dollar.


Although Schlafly proposes that the best way to empower women is to make job prospects better for men, that only works -- if it works at all -- for women who are able, or want, to marry.


What about the rest of them? What about other choices?


Simply put, even if every American man and woman wanted to marry, there are more women than men. Schlafly's math doesn't add up.


She also says, "Suppose the pay gap between men and women were magically eliminated. If that happened, simple arithmetic suggests that half of women would be unable to find what they regard as a suitable mate." That is, the more men that out-earn women, the more men there are from which those women might choose.


Reducing opportunity and financial independence for women does not empower them. In fact, the result is quite the opposite.


Of course, Schlafly's latest manifesto isn't about making logical arguments. She has long been known for courting controversy with her anti-feminism, anti-liberalism, anti-equal rights advocacy -- it's no surprise that she'd latch onto equal pay to further her own platform.


The truth is that a more likely deterrent to marriage is the higher tax burdens that married couples face. Under current tax codes, two-wage earning couples face higher taxes if they marry. This might be tolerable for middle class couples but is less so for those who earn less.


Economically speaking, there's greater incentive for young couples of modest means to forgo marriage entirely in favor of what Schlafly might regard as (gasp!) living in sin.


Schlafly's message is immensely disempowering for women, but what else would we come to expect from a woman who has made a career of telling women that their place is at home?


Perhaps more importantly, Schlafly's just got the whole "what women want" thing all wrong. Studies show that women are increasingly marrying men who are less educated and who earn less, too.


Could it be that these women are just taking what they can get? Or could it be that there's a new norm in town?


Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.


Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion.



No comments:

Post a Comment